Community as a Curse: The Pulp Trilogy Of Marleen Gorris

A photo of director Marleen Gorris
photo: Rob Bogaerts / Anefo, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

“We were born to unite with our fellow man, and to join in community with the human race.”
—Cicero

“We’re a virus with shoes.”
—Bill Hicks

Humans are a social animal, inherently drawn together to create shared systems of living. Another, more ominous word for “inherently” is “inevitably,” which carries the portent of doom. We are drawn together, perhaps inescapably so—the creation of these shared systems magnifies the intrinsic flaws in the characters of those who design them. If you think community is an innate virtue, just ask any outsider who has been pushed to the margins for defying what the collective has deemed the norm.

In the early works of the pioneering feminist filmmaker Marleen Gorris, community is a curse. The ideas explored in her first two films, A Question Of Silence (1982) and Broken Mirrors (1984), reach their apotheosis in The Last Island (1990), Gorris’ first English-language movie and perhaps the definitive statement in the first phase of her long career. Taken together, these first three films—which I’m just going to presumptuously dub her Pulp Trilogy—form a scathing indictment of not just any particular society but the very idea of society, observed with the chilly detachment of someone who’s surprised that you’re surprised.

***

Marleen Gorris is an answer to an excellent trick trivia question: Who is the first woman to win an Academy Award for her directorial work? The answer is not, in fact, Kathryn Bigelow, who won in 2009 for The Hurt Locker. Bigelow was the first woman to win Best Director, and also the first woman to direct a Best Picture winner. But Gorris’ fourth film, Antonia’s Line (1995), won Best Foreign Language Film way back in 1996. 

Of course, Gorris is much more than the answer to a trivia question. Born at the tail end of 1948 in the Netherlands, she began her film career late, and rather improbably: a small, seemingly inauspicious news item about an assault on a shopkeeper inspired her to write a script. Having no background in film, she showed the screenplay to Chantal Akerman, the Belgian filmmaker best known for Jeanne Dielman, 23, quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975). Akerman, plenty busy with her own work, suggested that Gorris make the movie herself. According to the book Film Fatales by Judith M. Redding and Victoria A. Brownworth, Akerman told the inexperienced screenwriter, “Directing isn’t all that hard.”

“Chantal was both right and wrong,” Gorris reflected. “The nuts and bolts of directing aren’t all that difficult. However, making a worthy film that people will remember is.”

Right and wrong, indeed. For a neophyte filmmaker, Gorris’ debut, A Question Of Silence—based on that screenplay she showed Akerman—is an exceptional movie, if the work of a novice behind the camera. From a minor kernel of a news story, Gorris spins out an audacious premise. Three women, with no apparent shared history or connection to their victim, brutally beat to death the owner of a dress shop. A psychiatrist—pointedly, a woman, played by Cox Habbema—is assigned by the authorities to interview the three accused criminals to determine their sanity. Through a series of conversations, the psychiatrist discovers that all three women, despite their vastly different lives and socio-economic backgrounds, share one thing in common: subjugation to a man, or to men, either in the form of a boss, an oafish husband, or hostile and often violent strangers. 

Gorris underscores her point when the psychiatrist, attempting to deliver her professional findings to an entirely male judiciary, is talked down to and talked over. They’re infuriated at her inability to find some tidy truth and completely deaf to the answers she does provide. They don’t like what they’re hearing, so they simply refuse to hear it. The three accused killers remain unrepentant. Meanwhile, a kind of rooting section of women has developed in the gallery. When the flummoxed judges silence the psychiatrist and order the accused to be removed from the courtroom, the killers and their coterie of supporters all point at the men and laugh, loudly and bitterly and damningly. 

For any man secretly terrified of being mocked or outperformed by a woman, A Question Of Silence might be the ultimate horror flick. It’s about as scathing a piece of feminist film as exists. It’s also a kind of perfectly sardonic indictment in that, if you don’t get it, you’re almost certainly part of the problem. The camera pulls in tight on the faces of the cackling women, their accusatory fingers pointing right out of the screen—at the judges in the courtroom, sure, but also at anyone in the audience confounded by what they’ve seen. 

Gorris displays exponential growth in both style and command as a filmmaker in her second film, Broken Mirrors. The two-pronged story sounds like the basis for a pretty standard grindhouse double feature: in one storyline, a group of sex workers struggle to maintain some sense of normalcy in a brothel where men come to indulge their basest impulses. Meanwhile, an anonymous serial killer stalks the streets, kidnapping women and tormenting them in a shabby basement dungeon before dumping their bodies in public. 

The two plots intertwine in a way that stymies the conventional expectations of either the cathartic carnage or performative nihilism common to exploitation cinema. The conclusion only underscores what’s clear much earlier on, which is that Gorris is working within the framework of exploitation movies but almost entirely subverting it. She toys with the tropes of sexploitation and B-movie murder plots without falling sway to their formulas. The brothel scenes are so blithely procedural that they have the vérité vibe of the quasi-documentary, while the serial-killer narrative unsparingly doles out all the sordid details without ever providing lurid thrills, predating Michael Haeneke’s careful-what-you-wish-for denouncement, Funny Games (1997). 

Oscars be damned: for my money, Broken Mirrors is Gorris’ masterpiece. Her novice status behind the camera was sometimes apparent throughout A Question Of Silence, in particular in the murder sequence, which is stiffly staged. The camerawork in Broken Mirrors isn’t so yeomanlike; it’s artfully controlled, shot with purpose and restraint. A slow pan down a nearly empty street is exactly as slow as it needs to be. There’s more intentionality to every movement, every cut. Gorris captures images in A Question Of Silence, but she crafts them in Broken Mirrors, with a total command of tone in service of a story that is thematically rich but never didactic. And it’s pretty clearly an indicator of her specific evolution as a filmmaker, because she worked with the same cinematographer, Frans Bromet, on both. 

Just as in A Question of Silence, community in Broken Mirrors is a failed state. The sex workers do their best to organize the brothel as a communal space, which Gorris nonjudgmentally portrays almost as a droll workplace drama. But of course it’s a business entirely focused on the desires of men, who bring the constant threat of objectification and violence. Not that it’s so much better beyond the walls of the brothel, where the killer stalks to the streets. In his few spare scenes we see that he easily masquerades as a fully accepted member of society—is, in fact, perhaps not such an outlier in this or any community. 

***

If you want to create a nice little social allegory, you’re gonna want to get yourself an island. The island is the obvious, irresistible microcosm for any storyteller seeking a small venue for big ideas. And cinema has provided a vast archipelago. The island can be an Edenic paradise despoiled by the arrival of humans—The Beach (2000), The Thin Red Line (1998)—a society recreated in miniature—Lord Of the Flies (1963), Battle Royale (2000), Hell In the Pacific (1968)—the incubator for a whole new way of living—The Island Of Dr. Moreau (1977), The Magus (1968)—or a purgatory removed from the heaven or hell of the outside world—Swiss Family Robinson (1960), Cast Away (2000), Blue Lagoon (1980).

The tropical locale in Gorris’ The Last Island isn’t quite a paradise, but it has the potential to be one. Mostly, it’s a science lab for Gorris to run a controlled social experiment, one that won’t yield hopeful resorts. 

A plane crashes, leaving only eight survivors—five men, two women, and a dog. Any notion of rescue is soon scuttled when a spin through the radio dial leads everyone to conclude that the plane crashed as a result of a nuclear blast, and that this island, for all intents and purposes, is now the last remaining vestige of humanity.

If the creators of Lost hadn’t seen The Last Island, I’d be surprised—their opening moments are nearly identical. The camera zooms in on the face of the island’s ultimate leader as their eyes snap open, suddenly awake on a beach next to the smoldering remains of a smashed airplane. In Lost, of course, that leader will be the classical, square-jawed TV hero, Jack. In The Last Island, it’s Mrs. Godame (Patricia Hayes), an older woman who will be shunted to the side of the action for much of the early going. And she seems mostly fine with that. But what the male characters will dismiss as the frailty and the perceived uselessness of an older woman will be revealed to be well-justified wariness over what is inevitably to come. “Don’t hope for rescue,” she warns. “Hope for something else.”

The one fellow castaway with great regard for Mrs. Godame is Joanna (Shelagh McLeod), the film’s ostensible protagonist. Joanna joins the men in gathering supplies and setting up some quasi-living quarters—one neat little detail involves separating everything from clothes to toiletries to books (classified by fiction and non-fiction!) to be stored in labeled suitcases. 

These early attempts at organization provide the slippery slope down which the castaways will slide, reverting not to their more animalistic selves but rather to the strictures and structures of their old society. It’s the curse of community come to life. The more they try to return to some sense of normalcy, the faster the decay spreads through the newly formed tribe. Every inch they move toward re-establishing the old order is another move closer to the edge.

The dread really thickens when the new islanders throw a social soirée, complete with booze and music and dress clothes. Joanna, who has flatly refused romantic contact with any of the men, becomes too sexualized in their eyes. Rather than resort to force, though, they turn to the oppressive discourse of community betterment. Isn’t it her duty as the only woman of child-bearing age to produce offspring? Even the more intellectual characters, the doctor and the naturalist, reluctantly bend to the idea of essentially making Joanna’s body community property.

And if you think Nick (Kenneth Colley)—the rigid German military man with a religious fixation—isn’t going to turn out to be a villain, well, you’ve never seen a Marleen Gorris movie—or maybe any movie, ever. (Certainly not Star Wars; Colley is instantly recognizable as the Imperial Admiral Piett.) Nick compulsively seizes authority, nominating himself to possess the island’s only rifle and eventually making snap autocratic decisions like cutting off the hand of a passenger who is bitten by a snake that may not even be poisonous. 

Nick leads the charge in the campaign to turn Joanna into the island’s resident baby factory while increasingly imposing his other ideas of order. Even the men who recognize the moral hazard of this approach can’t see the folly of their own macho response, leading to a total breakdown of the group. (As if responding to predictable #NotAllMen sentiment in the pre-hashtag era, Gorris even has the two gay characters join in on the bloodlust. Sorry again, dudes.)

The catastrophic breakdown of this island community is the only thing that spares Joanna. She and Mrs. Godame are far safer alone than they are under the protection of some makeshift society—which is and always will be, for women like them, prison. The final moments of the film echo the conclusion of Broken Mirrors and underscores Gorris’ larger thesis: women are better off alone.

***

Antonia’s Line, the 1996 Best Foreign Language Film winner and the movie for which Gorris is best known, is a shift into a new phase of her career. It’s difficult to imagine a harder zag, yet she remains steadfast in her thematic interests.

Whereas the Pulp Trilogy, reaching its apex with The Last Island, is partly about the corruptibility and corrupting influence of community, Antonia’s Line is an outright celebration of togetherness. The title character, the recently widowed Antonia (Willeke van Ammelrooy) returns to the Dutch village where she grew up, with her adult daughter Danielle (Els Dottermans) in tow. Antonia almost immediately sets about improving the community, empowering the dispossessed, exiling predators, and setting a standard for ethical living.

While the titular last island was a tabula rasa almost immediately stained by the presence of humanity, Antonia’s village is a functioning community beset with deep flaws. In these flaws we recognize Gorris’ familiar specters—tyranny, sexual violence—but here, Antonia is able to at least make progress toward often imperfect solutions, a prospect that seems impossible in the previous films. Gorris’ ethic hasn’t changed, but it’s a vision through a glass half full, darkly. “Isn’t it terrible that nothing exists?” Antonia’s child-prodigy granddaughter asks her as she learns about philosophy. Antonia responds, “That’s why there’s so much.”

Antonia’s Line began Gorris’ departure into literary adaptations and more English language films—Mrs. Dalloway (1997), The Luzhin Defense (2000)—and the romantic dramedy Carolina (2003). It’s not just a right but an imperative for any artist to grow, and these are fine films. With age comes wisdom and, often, temperance. Perhaps the marketplace was too hostile to such searing, cynical films, even couched within popular genres, although the many years it took for Gorris to secure financing for Antonia’s Line would argue against that. Perhaps Gorris’ attitudes softened, slightly—she never rebukes her earlier ideas, but she does take a more glass-half-full approach in her work, post-Pulp Trilogy. Whatever the reason, there’s a clear line of demarcation, even within a quite consistent filmography.

Maybe it’s my love of pulp and exploitation cinema, or the appeal to my misanthropy—probably it’s both—but I much prefer Gorris’ thornier early work. Scoffers might invoke words like ‘strident’ or ‘polemic’ to deride feminist films, but to me stridency is a virtue, and a polemic is a witheringly accurate description of a dire problem. Gorris’ Pulp Trilogy is exactly as uncompromising as it should be.