Laughing With the Pain

The Jackass Franchise

illustration by Ben Turner

All my friends were jumping off the cliff, so I did too. The quarry ledge somewhere deep in suburban Pennsylvania dropped 30, maybe 40 feet straight down into a pool of water beneath. Our nerves were building, the precarious view staring us dead in the eyes any time our glance cast down. But as soon as one of us—my then-boyfriend—jumped without warning and landed without harm, it burst the dam of reservations the rest of us had. Another friend followed suit, not thinking about it for more than a few seconds. But I hesitated, running every mental simulation of how the plunge could go wrong. The couple of friends still with me at the top of the cliff reminded me that I didn’t, in fact, have to do this, that I could just follow the path down to swim.

I don’t really know what compelled me to jump, but my legs acted faster than my thoughts. I felt myself in freefall and, before I could register any sense of fear, my body punctured the water. It wasn’t grace, but it wasn’t a panicked flailing either. It was something in between—the natural human beauty of throwing caution to the wind, turning my body over to whatever the moment would bring.

Frankly, it was out of character for me. Even back then, I would have described myself as beyond stupid decisions, peer pressure, what have you. But that’s the thing: when you believe you inhabit the body of a cisgender man impervious to any form of outside violence, you’re more foolhardy about throwing your own body in harm’s way. I thought so little of my own physical upkeep that it didn’t even register that I would want to be precious about my own body. It was a seemingly infinite commodity, simple as that. If I wanted to feel alive at all in those days, I had to push myself into danger to do so.

As I came to my senses in the cold water, and the rush subsided, I started laughing in sheer disbelief. Our stunt left us no worse off, coursing with adrenaline. The act was unquestionably dumb, but we found humor in the shared stupidity of it all. We were human, we were alive, and each of our bodies could be subjected to the same idiotic feats of audacity and humiliation.

***

It feels crucial that almost every Jackass segment ends with laughter before the fade out.

So much of the franchise—originally a television series broadcast on MTV, before growing into a four-film phenomenon—revolves around its cast subjecting themselves to arduous, painful, revolting, or death-defying acts. And so you need a release, a moment that breaks the tension of watching someone put themselves through something unpleasant, to remind the audience it’s okay to laugh—you’re laughing with the person going through hell. You’re reminded that—as much torture as the person onscreen is enduring—it’s ultimately an act they find fulfilling. They get something out of it, whether joy or humility or just a pure experiential rush.

One of my favorite moments in Jackass: The Movie comes at the very end of its most infamously gruesome stunt: “Paper Cuts.” Over the course of a couple minutes, we watch as Johnny Knoxville has the crew repeatedly slice the webbing between his fingers and toes with paper, even going over an already open wound one more time. Eventually, Steve-O joins in too, letting himself get cut on the tongue. Predictably, neither of the guys enjoys the act, but just before the segment ends, Steve-O shifts the mood with a deadpan quip: “God, am I glad I came down to see what was going on in this room.” Everyone laughs. Fade out.

Would any of us ever find relief at the other end of our pain if it weren’t for the company of others? Maybe that’s what brings us solace: the idea that, no matter what our bodies and spirits endure, we might be able to laugh it off with those we love.

I never watched Jackass before I transitioned; in part, I mistakenly thought it was purely a piece of crude, hypermasculine ‘boys’ media,’ the kind I was averse to even when I saw myself as a cisgender man. But there’s a palpable, undeniable bond that you sense the longer you spend with these men, one I never sensed in the boys I grew up with and wanted so badly to belong to. The Jackass crew is a group with an abrasive way of expressing their love for one another, but it’s a love language regardless. To be cared for, in the world of Jackass, is to subject your friends to outlandish feats of human endurance, blows that knock the wind out, staredowns with deadly wildlife, and blunt genital trauma. It’s knowing that the sweat and shit and semen you get dared into shedding, slathering, or swallowing is an expression of inclusion, of trust. An invitation to be debased is still an invitation.

Moments like Steve-O’s joke at the end of “Paper Cuts” also remind us of a perpetual truth of Jackass: no one ever goes through these torturous acts in isolation. Sometimes the series makes this literal, as in Jackass Number Two’s “Riot Control Test,” where Knoxville coaxes Bam Margera and Ryan Dunn—despite their vehement objections—into joining him in getting shot with hundreds of rubber balls. But Jackass always extends beyond whoever suffers in the spotlight, never shy about turning the camera to the cast members watching from the sidelines, or the several crew members just off in the periphery. So many stunts involve the guys crowding around to witness whatever their friends are willing to do, to cheer each other on during their respective moments in the limelight.

These reminders were what endeared me to Jackass where I thought I would be repelled. I came to the series late—a bandwagon-hopper upon Jackass Forever’s release in 2022—and found that these films transcended my misconceptions the more that they leaned into the communal, the fraternal. I quickly realized that many of my favorite segments were the ones where either everyone wants to get involved, or where those already pranked can’t resist bringing another member of their brethren in on the bit. The joys of something like “The High Five,” or “The Valentine,” or “The Jet Engine” lie in seeing more and more people brought into the fray, each falling prey to the pratfalls in their own way. Meanwhile, the laughter grows louder and louder, more voices adding to the chorus, before they fade out.

***

One of Jackass’s perpetual charms is that it feels like it can belong to anybody, that anybody can become a part of it. There’s an endearingly romantic quality in the murkiness and low fidelity of the digital video camcorders used for Jackass: The Movie, as though you’d stumbled across the perverse DIY tapes of any number of guys you might know. The cinematographic intimacy and low-stakes nature of these early affairs is, in itself, a kind of rhetorical invitation for the viewer, a shorthand for proximity and verisimilitude: the men onscreen are not all that different from you or me.

There’s a lineage to this kind of style, most transparent in the first Jackass film’s tip to its roots in skate culture. Like Jackass, underground skate videos of the 1980s and ‘90s offered glimpses into what any skating community might be like—what tricks a crew might want to show off, what music it associates with its style, what the collective camaraderie might be. These videos, too, were a kind of invitation for viewers, a way for fellow skaters or enthusiasts to feel a part of otherwise inaccessible spaces. And to be given a chance to witness is to be given a chance to be included.

As Jackass grew as a cultural institution, and the budget of each film exponentially followed, the films mitigated the potential distancing factor this might yield through simple means: expanding the pool of who could be part of a Jackass stunt. Celebrities like Tony Hawk, Mat Hoffman, Henry Rollins, and John Waters were always part of the early days of the movies, but the growth of the main cast in Jackass Forever, now rounded out by new blood who grew up with the series, represented a different kind of inclusion. The overarching message remained clear: if you were eager to be part of the escapades, you were welcome in the world of Jackass, no matter how big the series and its stunts became.

The fluidity of who belongs to Jackass shows through in the films’ own internal rhythms, never dwelling on a single person over the rest, never inordinately emphasizing any particular coupling from its cast. It would go against the ethos of Jackass to have anything diminish its collective nature. You can take nearly any random sequence in any Jackass movie and apply this principle. (For example, the run in Jackass Number Two where “The Fish Hook” gives Steve-O a solo platform, then has a brief cutaway for Bam Margera’s “Velcro Jump,” pivots to multiple cast members playing “The Electric Stool” prank on Wee-Man, and finally lets Johnny Knoxville have a daredevil moment of his own with the “Yak Charge.”) Everyone gets a moment to shine or bail or scream or puke, and everyone gets to celebrate and suffer together.

In chronologically progressing through the Jackass movies, I became aware of the disarming richness of this group dynamic the further I went along. You march forward in time with the cast and see them change and shift over years of physical trauma and horrifying scatalogical torment. You come to see them as familiar friends, catching glimmers of both the old charms and the exciting joys of a person ever-so-subtly shifting with age. I hadn’t been expecting, in this act of marathoning, to be touched by the grace notes at the end of the final two films: montages over credits calling back to the gang’s early days, intercutting between home movies, clips from the MTV show, present-day footage, and—most poignantly, in Jackass Forever—archival footage paying tribute to Ryan Dunn after his death in 2011.

There’s a lot of earnest love buried underneath every moment of Jackass, beneath the onslaught of dicks and shit that most immediately take up the frame. But these montages telegraph that earnestness as openly as possible. There’s no irony or distance, no playful antagonism. Just heartfelt appreciation for these guys embracing the lifelong bonds they have—the place each has in the others’ lives, the joy they bring one another.

***

As a trans woman, I belong to a demographic more statistically prone to pain than most people who appear in a Jackass film. Whether that pain is doled out emotionally, physically, or some combination of the two, I exist with an ever-present knowledge that its likelihood hovers over me far more than it ever did when I saw myself as a cisgender man. I live as a person at higher risk for abuse, assault, and fatal violence.

Yet I’ve never once questioned whether that should get in the way of living as I am. Even knowing what might be at stake, even knowing how precarious this life may be, I’ve never once wanted to discard the greater joy that comes with this risk, the joy I find on my own terms. That’s ultimately what keeps me going through transition, no matter how fraught forces outside my control make it: why discount how much life I’m finally living just because others exert the looming threat of pain over me? Why suppress who I am because of how another sees me, how another wishes me harm?

But there’s another side to the relationship between transness, pain, and joy—a relationship of pain on one’s own terms, entirely within a trans person’s own volition and autonomy. Pain as a pathway to better understanding your own body, pain as a vessel for expression, pain as a reclamation of that which otherwise lives outside your control.

An example: at present, I’m willingly immersed in a yearlong process of getting my junk zapped by lasers, on a near-monthly basis, to prepare for a surgery that will render the entire area an even bigger pain nexus for three full months of recovery. This comes after years of routine laser treatments fired across my face to minimize facial hair, and plans to increase the pain intensity in both areas with electrolysis to mop up whatever lighter hairs still linger. Yet, I do this because the emotional pain of living with a body outside my own control is far worse for me to bear. Sharper pain that offers catharsis and a finite ending is preferable to living with an abstracted pain for the rest of my life.

A funny thing comes with belonging to trans communities: you bond over the absurdity of your common pain—in all senses. Over the years, my bonds with close trans friends have grown just as strong by venting about harassment and institutional violence as they have by making jokes about what we put ourselves through to be at peace in our own bodies. Dumb comedy about laser and electrolysis and surgeries becomes as commonplace as sincere updates about our lives and transitions. If there is a saving grace to all the discomfort and hurt we go through in transition, it’s knowing that we can find others like us, others we can trust with our pain. And, most importantly, others with whom we can laugh about our experiences, who also recognize the humor in our very existence.

The more I’ve come to understand how to process and reclaim my pain, the more I actively seek out safe conduits for that very same pain with others who want to do the same. I frequent local trans punk shows in my city, where hundreds of trans women congregate to find release and community by beating the shit out of each other in the mosh pit. (While writing this essay, I left one of these shows with two chipped teeth after being accidentally bashed in the face by a friend, notching battle scars not dissimilar to those Steve-O and Danger Ehren have weathered.) In aiming to better know how my body’s transness intersects with growing chronic pain, I entrust the exploration of my physical limits to friends and loved ones through kink and sexuality, reconfiguring the most unpleasant sensations I feel day to day into a form of pleasure.

The other curious thing that’s emerged in my years of transitioning is learning just how many trans friends have their own personal love for Jackass, their own ways of finding resonance in watching these cisgender men (and, now, also Rachel Wolfson) torment themselves for our collective amusement. Upon Jackass Forever’s release in 2022, those very same all-trans group chats became flooded with everyone’s takes on the latent transness of Jackass, interjected between life updates and expressions of support. We’d remark how many of the stunts resembled what we go through just to get our bodies as we want them—the barrage of electricity stunts like “The Quiet Game” and “Electric Tap Dance” akin to our electrolysis, the stinging pain of “Scorpion Botox” not unlike our hair removal sessions and facial feminization surgeries. In reference to all of these, one friend simply joked, “This would be easy for us. We already go through stuff this painful.” Another, after a rewatch of Jackass 3D, wrote, “Very funny to see the gang writhe at milder versions of shit I’ve been through myself. If they can get through ‘Electric Avenue,’ then I can deal with whatever my own system is unleashing on me.” We look at the torture onscreen, and see an odd sense of recognition, realizing that it isn’t totally unfamiliar for us, that we similarly channel pain for our own actualizations.

Almost every day I spent online during Jackass Forever’s release, I was all but guaranteed to come across a trans person in my network musing about how natural it would be to have “an all-trans Jackass.” Deep down, I think we all sensed the ways that Jackass, as we saw it, was a kind of community-building, of getting closer to those you love by partaking in the stupidest, most humiliating, most dangerous acts imaginable. You wouldn’t do the kinds of things that happen in a Jackass film in front of just anyone. The most ideal way to endure those kinds of pain is with those you feel the closest to.

When I threw Jackass: The Movie on with my girlfriend while first conceptualizing this essay, we found a kind of shared revulsion when we hit “Paper Cuts.” Immediately, we started wincing in unison, covering each other’s eyes. And yet, it felt far more tolerable than watching that scene alone. A shared agony—still agonizing, but shared nonetheless.

***

It’s a very open secret at this point that everyone—even the Jackass cast themselves—understands the series as a celebration of all things queer-coded. As time went on, the gang leaned into this further, unafraid to homoerotically disrobe and get intimate with each other’s genitals. Before long, Chris Pontius drops all pretext and spends half of each movie cross-dressing.

Of all the invitations that Jackass lends the viewer, this is the one that feels the most significant to me. Jackass and its male-dominated energy could have so easily tilted into a fearfully exclusionary entity, obnoxiously bombarding the viewer with off-color humor while emanating a fervent “no homo” energy. And yet, the cast deliberately leaned in the opposite direction. Jackass got gayer and more progressive as time went on, shearing its more mean-spirited or racist thorns, pushing toward wearing its open heart on its sleeve, no matter how many bodily fluids are shed on-camera.

It feels poignant to me that most of my friends who are into Jackass identify as queer in some capacity. It becomes this object we can wax poetic about without any hint of irony—a conduit for our own bonding, a means to momentarily displace our own pain by laughing with the pain of others.

There’s a lyric from MJ Lenderman’s “You Are Every Girl to Me”—released just months after Jackass Forever—that embodies a truism deeper than even he likely intended: “Jackass is funny / Like the Earth is round.” Inside the bluntness and authority of these lines is an implied common understanding; all of us can feel at home in the cathartic pleasures of physical comedy. Jackass has the power to pull us closer and make us forget about the forces that want to tear us apart. We’re reminded that pain is universal. But in these men’s laughter, we’re reminded that the same is true of the joy we find on the other side of it.