Rat on the Monument

A feminist dirtbag reconsideration of Boston cinema after divorce

Photo by Mark Olsen on Unsplash

“It ruined my life, literally, but I’m proud.”

If “Boston cinema” is a trope anyone recognizes, that’s Matt Damon and Ben Affleck’s legacy. They refreshed and relocated a cinematic archetype of masculinity: the wounded white man in a crewneck and button-down, dropping his Rs, drinking his feelings, punishing patient women with his emotional damage, and pretending not to be in love with his best friend.

Matt and Ben’s road to stardom is now Hollywood folklore. They met early as schoolmates, and shared child-acting careers, hypersmart single mothers, and loose ties to Harvard: Matt did three years but chose Geronimo: An American Legend (1993) over a degree, Ben’s mom got a master’s, and Ben’s dad was, would you believe, a campus janitor. Matt and Ben co-wrote a screenplay; attached Robin Williams, Gus Van Sant, and Harvey Weinstein; and made Good Will Hunting (1997). They threw their arms around each other and their twin Oscars. They brought their moms as their red carpet dates. They were crowned. So was Boston. 

With that 1997-98 crowning came a turn-of-the-millenium enshrining of Boston’s cinematic code: a story about Boston is a story about white masculinity. But there is a hole in this Boston code’s bucket, and it encircles everything white masculine conformity must name an enemy to survive: principally femininity and homosexuality, but with them individuality, authenticity, originality, and diversity. Good Will Hunting, The Departed (2006), and Spotlight (2015) all illustrate how the same conditions that foster homophobia and misogyny—a socially conservative, patriarchally Catholic cultural emphasis on shame, conformity, and tradition—also fertilize abuse, secrecy, and deceit. In addition to torpedoing intimacy in heterosexual romantic partnership, these films demonstrate how this ingrained cultural repression forecloses other intimacies: emotional intimacy, familial intimacy, trust, vulnerability, transparency, disclosure. 

This aperture leaks a seminal despair into the Ben and Matt cinematic mythology, and into all the films I’ll dissect—primarily the three aforementioned, with particles of The Town, Gone Baby Gone, Argo, and Live by Night. The Town (2010) epigraphs this despair: “I’m proud to be from Charlestown. It ruined my life, literally, but I’m proud.” 

I have, to understate the case both comically and tragically, a conflicted relationship with this archetype and its hometown: I married and divorced one of its progeny. I have a problem with Boston in the sense that it sold me a bill of goods and I am still paying off the interest. These films all dramatize such an indenture, and hold certain properties in common. First, I have, until now, dreaded and avoided close-reading them like a local regards Storrow Drive at 5pm, fearing long entrapment. Second, paradoxically, I have seen them multiple times. Third, none could pass the Bechdel or DuVernay tests with a gallon of Metamucil. Fourth, they are parables of masculinity and heterosexuality that illustrate how those paradigms are violently enforced. Fifth, they address the connection between child abuse and adult failure to thrive. And sixth, of course, they are all set in Boston. 

My bizarre and probably irredeemable preoccupation with Ben Affleck conducts much of this investigation. Whether writing, directing, acting—or all three—Affleck’s films tend to follow the same Campbellian structure: sudden emergency, elaborate heist, thrilling execution. Ben serves as the brainy hero who shepherds plot to execution: as FBI agent Tony Mendez in Argo (2012), as Irish mob boss Joe Coughlin in Live by Night (2016), and as hockey has-been Doug MacRay in The Town (2010). Ben is always conjuring an extraordinary ragamuffin who manages to save and seduce without sobering up or sleeping—even when Matt is tapped to stand in this role, most notably in Good Will Hunting. 

This Boston hero’s secreted, special powers must deploy certain load-bearing narrative assets. The hero must generate whispers from the Catholic choruses of Jamaica Plain, Charlestown, and Southie about his unusual intelligence and potential. The hero must tote an entourage of bros he’s known since first communion, and must be wrenched by internal conflict about how much smarter he is than they are. He must attain the purring, neglected desire of a thin, capitalistically beautiful, white-passing woman with no credible Boston accent: Blake Lively, Minnie Driver, Rebecca Hall, Vera Farmiga, Taylor Schilling. Importantly, a Boston hero is desired by women, who are also desired by, yet inattentive to, other men—if she stops desiring him, that’s her damage. In this bellicose, self-mythologizing way, Ben serves up Boston’s denomination of a ruggedly individualistic American antihero-cum-hero: the sexy, taciturn, drunk, ethnic-white, underrested, hostile, misunderstood genius, loyal to and performing for his homosocial male coterie, underdelivering at life and overachieving at transgression. 

Ben Affleck’s first credited film as a director pledges allegiance to these Boston values. His first short film, dated 1993, is titled I Killed My Lesbian Wife, Hung Her on a Meat Hook, and Now I Have a Three-Picture Deal at Disney. 

***

“You owe it to me.”

A feminist dirtbag synopsis of the relationships that comprise Good Will Hunting’s monomyth: in its ordinary world, Matt Damon1 is a sad, ripped MIT janitor and Ben Affleck is a sad, ripped construction worker. Their working-class whiteness and grim industrial tableaux telegraph the Southie setting. Matt and Ben are, tacitly, everything to one another. The operative irony of the present-progressive title instructs us that Will Hunting is not quite good, has not quite located himself; it silhouettes a ruggedly individualistic, taciturn, drunk, hostile, misunderstood genius on a quest. Good Will Hunting charts its hero’s acceptance of his own damage, vulnerability, and growth potential as proxy for his acceptance of his intelligence and aptitude for social mobility.

Matt doodles complex math on the blackboard for fun while he cleans classrooms. Matt gets into a fight. Thanks to the self-interested intervention of MIT math professor Stellan Skarsgård, Matt eludes jail through a dispatch to his threshold and guardian: budget therapy with Robin Williams at Bunker Hill Community College, a landmark dingy but recognizable for its connection to Boston’s omniscient obelisk. Robin joins the rehabilitation effort from the boundaried distance of a scheduled, paid clinical appointment, and teaches Matt the gravitas of love in a poignant story about his late wife farting in her sleep. The nameless, beatifically dead wife is, of course, unavailable to corroborate.

The film’s core love story remains eternally the sinewy, homosocial, feckin-A-laced, Carhartt-outfitted working-class pose within which Matt and Ben embrace. Robin and Ben catalyze the upward mobility that the film implies is Matt’s destiny from orthogonal vectors of his life, while Minnie provides flesh for this change’s stakes. Robin primes Matt’s emotional pump with his hard-lived stories of vulnerability and intimacy, but it is incontrovertibly Ben who motivates Matt toward the abandonment of familiarity that successful social climbing will require. It is not therapy but Ben’s urging that convinces Matt to pursue the girl and the math job over staying on construction sites with him. Robin shows Matt that nests exist. But Ben pushes Matt out of theirs with wincing, self-sacrificing love: “Fuck you. You don’t owe it to yourself. You owe it to me.” Ben’s single monologue decodes the balance of GWH’s homosocial dialogue: after hearing it, we know that all the previous times Matt and Ben have spit go fuck yourself at each other with their Marlboro-and-Dunkin’ breath, what they really meant was I love you, man. 

Criminally few considerations of Good Will Hunting observe that, in it, Matt is both playing and engaging Ben’s entire family. Matt Damon is the child of a stockbroker and a professor of early childhood education who grew up in a hippie “community house.” Affleck’s mother was also a Harvard-educated teacher, but his father worked in Boston-area theater and “had a more working-class lifestyle. He didn’t go to college. He was an auto mechanic and a bartender and a janitor at Harvard.” Affleck told Barbara Walters: “[My father] was an alcoholic. . . . I did know that as a child. He drank a lot. My father was a—what did they call him—a real alcoholic. He, you know, drank all day, drank every day, and to his credit, he got sober ultimately.”

Good Will Hunting inaugurates the Affleckian hero’s journey out of Affleckian family history; its only divergence from the structure of Argo, Gone Baby Gone, The Town, or Live by Night is placing a Damon rather than Affleck body at its center. The sudden emergency is Matt’s arrest, the elaborate heist is Matt eluding jail for therapy, and the stunning execution is Matt processing just enough trauma to withstand a smart-people job and a girl also destined for one. No other male-male star pairing has fostered a more public masculine intimacy together. Good Will Hunting is the star vehicle Matt and Ben co-created in order to transplant Ben’s psyche into Matt’s body: it amounts to a merging of their bodies and psyches through story, image, and capital.

The meaning of this merging, to me, exists somewhere in the inchoate, arguably corrupt gray area between homosociality and heteropessimism. As Asa Seresin defined the term in The New Inquiry in 2019, “Heteropessimism consists of performative disaffiliations with heterosexuality, usually expressed in the form of regret, embarrassment, or hopelessness about straight experience. Heteropessimism generally has a heavy focus on men as the root of the problem.” Though heteropessimism is primarily exhibited by jaded straight women, Seresin also tracks a sect of zealous male heteropessimists called Men Going Their Own Way, who “are encouraged to form homosocial self-care communities that will both shield and heal them from romantic trauma, ensuring a kind of prolonged anesthesia of the heart.” Matt and Ben’s litany of characters, especially in Good Will Hunting, perform disaffiliation with heterosexuality both through their suspiciousness of women and through their preoccupation with each other. The working-class bro-scape of Good Will Hunting—much like the organized crime of The Town and The Departed, and even the corrupt clergy of Spotlight—is nothing if not a story of a profoundly broken homosocial self-care community of separatist men.

The codes of this homosocial community are enforced by how the film’s diction fuses the threat of violence with the promise of solidarity: for example, as Casey hesitates to join the fight which will prove Matt’s inciting event, Ben hisses at him, “let me tell you something, if you’re not out there in two fucking seconds, then you’re next.” Or, alternatively, the film’s opening scene hears Ben’s character tell a story about a cousin killing one cat with his car and beating another to death with a hammer. Ben’s character is described as “the guy holding court…the largest of the bunch….loud, boisterous, a born entertainer”; Matt’s is “handsome and confident, a soft-spoken leader.” Just a couple of good-looking guys in a bar, regaling each other with stories about murdering pussy. 

This violent bonding also disguises admiration and flirtation as banter and derogation. At a batting cage, Ben proposes to Matt that they visit a Harvard bar where a friend is bouncing. “What are we gonna do up there?” Matt asks. “I don’t know, we’ll fuck up some smart kids. You’d probably fit right in.” This is as explicit a compliment as has ever been issued in the Boston metro area. Seresin calls heteropessimism “an anesthetic feeling: a feeling that aims to protect against overintensity of feeling and an attachment that can survive detachment.” In other words, a backhanded compliment from your performatively aloof best male friend is safer than being vulnerable to a clingy woman. 

***

Fugue in B Major

In the first six months after my divorce, I made a lot of uncomfortable jokes. Whenever I met someone with any connection to the state, I would mention with deliberate nonchalance: oh, I’m considering filing suit against the entire Commonwealth of Massachusetts. For what? For the systematic murder of at least ten generations of male feelings. Through their strained laughter no one ever asked why. 

Divorce is embarrassing even though it shouldn’t be, and so is writing about divorce. It’s humiliating to feel out loud, to know that all my healing processes will entwine themselves with feeling in print, because feeling in print is my job, and because it became my job out of its long service as my primary coping mechanism for living. Writing is embarrassing like going into a drugstore for literally any reason is embarrassing: I leak, I hurt, I burn, I need, I falter. 

I hate embarrassment, but I hate the volatility and violence of unacknowledged feelings even more. 

My coping mechanism sometimes announces itself as its own psychological event. What my psychological events hold most in common with Matt Damon’s is that occasionally they involve entering a creative fugue state, coming to, and then realizing I’ve written 8000 words about Ben Affleck.

***

“How very unfortunate, I think, for me.”

No matter how actively alcoholic, traumatized, codependent, and mutually besotted Matt and Ben are in GWH’s homosocial fantasy, the enactment of its hero’s journey still mandates heterosexuality via the romantic pursuit of a woman. And this is where Matt becomes a magnetic plane for female heteropessimistic desire: if hot, smart, and emotionally broken is the best a straight woman MD-to-be can hope for, well, then, pass the French Vanilla Regulah. 

Accordingly, Matt meets his goddess/temptress Minnie Driver, a rich, orphaned, brilliant Harvard medical student, at the dingy Harvard bar that Ben proposed. Matt obtains Minnie’s phone number and lords it over a Harvard asshole—bigfooting richer men, never forget, is the most valuable opportunity presented in a girl’s contact—by slamming it into a bar window with the declaration How do you like them apples. 

Minnie enters to prove Matt’s desirability, then serves to reflect his damage and his potential alike: they’ve both got brains enough to spar with the Harvard kids, but unlike him she has money, a white-coat career path, and the capacity to face adversity without punching anybody. Her Medical Madonna Pixie, replete with dirty jokes and goofy glasses, milemarks Matt’s progress on his mission of social mobility without boundary, compensation, or dialogue with anybody beyond Matt and Ben.

Female heteropessimism—much like the definition of beauty as “not good capital” in sociologist Tressie McMillan Cottom’s “In the Name of Beauty,” from Thick—delineates an essential, unresolvable tension: it signifies an unceasing, expensive pursuit of a status symbol which is definitionally not worth its cost. The only basis upon which a logical woman would assume she has any leverage against entrenched psychological damage like Will Hunting’s is the belief that she, uniquely, contains sufficient internal resources to fix him. 

As the film tracks their romance, Matt’s healing is slow and his resistance fierce, and Minnie’s position in his emotionally underdeveloped present inevitably makes her more the casualty of his ineptitude than the beneficiary of his growth. Matt deadasses her that he doesn’t love her when he does. Matt lies to her about having 11 brothers while she navigates the painfully real grief of losing her entire immediate family. Matt acts out his mournful, violent rage while Minnie quietly, quirkily learns to save lives. In this fantasia on male vulnerability, the female goodwill such an arc requires is all hers; indeed, there is no more classic Hollywood hero’s journey than a woman hurt in service of a man’s self-actualization. After Matt finally tells Robin he’s got to go see about a girl, the evidence the film’s conclusion offers about how Matt will treat Minnie thereafter exists in how he has treated her heretofore: cruelly, enviously, unfairly, and inconsistently. The film, in argument and airtime, insists that the emotional journey of an abused, abusive man provides a fascinating and worthy A-plot because he has potential, and that a hardworking, high-achieving woman rates a diminutive C-plot because she has no visible mental illness and more inherited wealth.

Heteropessimism emerges from a girl like Minnie’s culturally conditioned conviction that she can fix a boy like Matt, and the near-inevitable failure of this mission’s execution. Good Will’s romantic construction stacks its odds within this distance precisely: Matt stands to gain social mobility through coupling with a Harvard- and Stanford-educated physician touting inherited wealth, and Minnie stands to gain the diminishing returns of commitment to a violent, dishonest alcoholic, alumnus of a few months of court-ordered therapy. But he’s really good at math. 

***

It & that & The Obelisk

Anyone can critique a film, but why am I so mad at Good Will Hunting, a kindhearted, bloodwarm film about vulnerability, intimacy, and healing, with the peerless Robin Williams at its center? 

Because I feel duped: by how the film’s narrative orientation cajoles me to root for a man who bestows lies and cruelty upon a kind woman; by how often and multifariously I’ve been asked by narrative and culture to root for a man’s growth at a woman’s expense; that no parent or girlfriend or mentor of Minnie’s is granted airtime to warn her of Matt’s garish red flags; by how Matt is playing Ben and Ben is playing Ben’s father and Harvey fucking Weinstein is pulling all the strings and they all got Oscars for it. Every heist needs a patsy. All the better if she can save a few lives before she cooks dinner. 

Duped, of course, is just another word for embarrassed. 

The act of translating go fuck yourself to I love you, man requires effort. Of translation, of forcing a smile. Of self-convincing that we can help them. 

My taciturn ex had a habit of dropping his nouns, leaving pronouns unattached to subjects. You can’t say that. What can’t I say? I don’t agree with it. You don’t agree with what? Somehow the subjects remained unnamed; somehow I was just supposed to know. Like he was still living in a hometown where everybody knew everybody and I was still learning that language, and at the same time we’d been living together on a different coast for years. 

It and that: they wield a vague, vast power. Decoding, explaining, interpreting, arguing: these are synonyms for time and energy. 

In failing to grasp New England’s customs and conventions, I invented my own private language. I irritated my ex by calling the Leonard P. Zakim Bunker Hill Memorial Bridge—the bridge Leo and Jack speed across in The Departed while The Dropkick Murphys bellow I LOST MY LEG— “the obelisk.” 

Why? I just needed to feel some sense of agency, however fictitious or pretentious, in identifying my surroundings. And I needed to mock how fucking phallic that bridge is. Like, of course one of the most famous landmarks in Boston is a giant, erect, circumcised, concrete penis. 

I needed to desecrate the monument. I was reaching for the graffiti can with a left hand still wearing a diamond ring. I wanted to slap that big dick in the face. I didn’t. 

***

“Marriage is an important part of getting ahead.”

I have been avoiding The Departed as fervently as Will Hunting sprints from feelings.

The Departed is a schlocky movie and a fantastic movie, in which Leonardo DiCaprio gives one of his most miscast performances in one of the most felonious accents ever committed to celluloid. It is a film I quote regularly, and a film I think represents most of the evils in the world. It ends with a rat scampering across a Boston landmark. I’ve seen it a dozen times. 

The Departed presents a separatist coterie of homosocial masculinity not unlike Good Will Hunting’s, but in its tonal pivot from warmhearted to coldhearted, its ensemble replaces male therapists and math daddies with ruthless kingpins, dirty cops, and a multiply-sexualized female therapist. Matt Damon is a fake Statie who’s really the adoptive son and criminal proxy to Kingpin Daddy Jack Nicholson, a cultural icon of cocaine and womanizing. Leonardo DiCaprio is a fake mobster in Jack’s crew who’s really working for Statie Daddy Martin Sheen, a cultural icon of leftist Catholicism. Leo and Matt are both unusually smart kids from roughneck Southie backgrounds. The double agents spend the film circling each other as almost every minor player proves to be another double agent, dies, or both. The film studs its action to binaries: Madonna or whore, criminal or law enforcement, loyalist or rat. 

A film about phonies inevitably collides and colludes with sexual deceit. We learn that Matt can’t get it up when his therapist fiancee, Vera Farmiga aka Wonderful Counselor, tries to coax him out of his embarrassment: “Guys tend to make too big a deal out of it.” That phantom It again: this time a hard cock, a man’s ego, the secret with which he tasks his woman. Not much later, his boss Baldwin asks Matt how the wedding is coming along:

“Marriage is an important part of getting ahead. Lets people know you’re not a homo. Married guy seems more stable. People see the ring, they think, at least somebody can stand the son of a bitch. Ladies see the ring and they know immediately you must have some cash and your cock must work.” 

Matt agrees: “Yeah, it’s working. Overtime.” 

Alec, in a slimy gravel: “I’m glad to hear that.” 

The ring is a prophylactic against embarrassment. Yet in the previous scene, Wonderful Counselor was boning Leo to “Comfortably Numb” performed live. Two scenes later, Matt will rendezvous with Jack’s giant prosthetic cock in a porn theater. 

Within these fragments, sexual desire becomes another moral battleground across which each character’s true nature is revealed. Matt is lying to Alec about his cock’s functionality, and to Wonderful Counselor about who it chases all day. Matt and Alec are lying to each other and themselves that there’s no flirtation between them in this graphic exchange of socially instructive sexual information. Wonderful Counselor is lying to Matt about Leo, and to herself about these men’s trustworthiness. She knows that Matt lies and chooses to accept that under the auspices of his job. The ring presents an alibi for both home and work. First priority is never letting anyone suspect you’re an impotent homo.

There is only one line in The Departed which I philosophically love, still partially unprintable here. Nicholson, as Whitey Bulger cipher Frank Costello, opens the film with a monologue about power. He addresses the African-American community in the Bostonian custom, which is to say he drops two anti-Black slurs including the N-word within the film’s first two minutes. “If I got one thing against the black ch*****s,” he says, “it’s this: No one gives it to you. You have to take it.” 

“It” rings out loud and vague here. It stands for power. But it also stands for money, respect, territory, means of production, agency, authority, pleasure, happiness, satisfaction, dominance, status, ownership, and freedom. Its vagueness elides that none of these are quite the same thing. 

It doesn’t matter. Whatever it is, you cannot wait for permission, or expect it to be granted to you. You simply have to take it. 

***

“…it really needs to stand alone.” 

My favorite Boston movie, which penetrates an essential, poisoned core like no Affleck instrument, is Spotlight. Unlike these other films, Spotlight depicts historical events that I vividly remember. The Boston Globe’s 2002 exposé of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church occasioned my first, and I am often sorry to say not my last, exit from the Catholic faith.

Spotlight captures a fundamental American koan: that every American city of influence operates by a code, an organizing principle, a life force. Los Angeles is fame through beauty. D.C. is power. New York City was once art and is now money. San Francisco rose from vice, sprouted tech, then merged the two. 

Boston’s code is silence. Through silence, to silence, by silence. Silence as tradition, custom, and conduct. Silence’s only interruption as the insult which demands more silence. What, you think you’re better than us? Shut the fuck up. 

I find Spotlight to be not just a moving but a compulsively watchable film because its primary narrative action is not violation, but the iterative, investigative process by which violent secrecy is revealed. Its story arraigns the banal evils of bureaucracy as much as the graphic horrors of abuse. It understands an essence of corruption: that just as an upper class requires an underclass, just as white supremacy requires the subaltern of color, these horrors of abuse require those evils of bureaucracy. That after the innocent child wrongly touched, there are the parents deferent to the priest, the cops ready to drop the charge, the archdiocese content to transfer the priest to a darker or poorer parish, the lawyers eager to settle out of court. And then there are the reporters poised to dismiss the whistleblower as a kook, the courthouse employees willing to bury a few sensitive files, the fundraisers thirsty to keep influential names out of the paper, the editors clad in the same class rings as the fundraisers. And priests. And lawyers. And the friends who stop calling, and the eyes on your back at the Market Basket. These concentric circles of harm build a city, and an experience: a life.   

Spotlight argues far more intentionally than Good Will Hunting or The Departed that silence is not an individual action but a socially enforced cultural mandate, and that institutional inclusion conditionally predicated on silence and conformity is no safety at all. It depicts how those who break that silence are exiled from the family, the church, respectable society, and their protection, all but guaranteeing that individual sexual trauma precedes collective cultural trauma. 

Liev Schrieber’s Globe editor Marty Baron in Spotlight directly challenges the poisoned premise of this solidarity. In an obligatory meeting with Cardinal Law, the cardinal unctuously offers Schrieber his collaboration, saying, “I find that the city flourishes when its great institutions work together.” 

Schrieber resists the strings attached to this apparent generosity. “Thank you. Personally, I’m of the opinion that for the paper to perform its best function it really needs to stand alone.” Here Spotlight illuminates its own conflicted binaries: between conformity and disclosure, popularity and justice, inclusion and exclusion. 

The film lights its side of these moral streets through its deliberate lack of aesthetic sumptuousness. Boston is a dingy city and Spotlight a dingy movie. It’s beige as a cubicle, sketchily lit, absent any wardrobe element that’d cost more than a family dinner of Kelly’s Super Beefs. The film’s master shots are calculated, not beautiful: a courthouse-bound cab carries a reporter over the obelisk bridge and passes an abuse survivor pushing his young son on a creaking playground swing, lonesome on a cloudy day.  

Contrast this with how Francis Ford Coppola maneuvers the Catholic aesthetic: intercutting mob assassinations with a baptism featuring his own infant daughter, a glittering crucifix opposite bloody fangs. David Chase: a crackling fireplace backlighting Father Intintola pressing a communion wafer onto Carmela Soprano’s quivering, extended tongue. Martin Scorsese: Nicholson sliding on his sunglasses to tell Sheen, “Excuse me, I’ve got a date with some angels.” Even without a community college therapist we intuit that these auteurs host tangled wires around sexuality, transgression, and authority.

I revere Spotlight’s refusal to defer to patriarchal Catholic authority within its visual unwillingness to glamorize the voodoo aesthetic. A story of bleakness, secrecy, and harm is justly served by dinginess. The film’s only Christmas carols augment soundscapes of typing and sobbing. Nothing glitters. You can’t smell the incense. Breathe deep into Spotlight and you’ll only smell wet newsprint, half a Marlboro Light, and a rat rotting in the basement. 

And that is how Boston actually smells. 

***

“I am as God made me.”

Spotlight intersects with The Departed when Nicholson lectures two priests at a diner. 

“You recall our chat? Little boys. Sucking on their peckers, et cetera and so forth. I am as God made me. Was that your rationale? May I remind you, in this archdiocese, God don’t run the bingo.”

This highlights the open secret of clergy abuse, but not Costello’s heroism or protection of the community. It’s Costello demonstrating that his dick—obelisk, that, it—is so big in Boston that even its abusive priests fear him. Costello owns the city by owning its institutions: the Feds, the Staties, and most of all the archdiocese. Costello took it. 

Yet Costello gestures elsewhere toward his own interest in child sexual abuse: as her father flinches silently, he asks a young corner store clerk, “You get your period yet, Carmen?” In Boston, real power resides not in owning property, but in owning the arbiters of its codes. And those who own them flex their power by abusing children with impunity. 

***

Open tabs

I love Spotlight because I know the cost of breaking silence. I love Good Will Hunting because I’ve loved men who cannot pay it. I love The Departed because I love espionage, and I love espionage because I love double lives, and I love double lives because I lived them for almost 40 years. 

After my first film’s red-carpet premiere at the Tribeca Film Festival, he screamed at me in a hotel room until dawn because we hadn’t gotten the picture together he wanted. I hadn’t paid enough attention to him that day. He was embarrassed. 

I withstood hemorrhaging, blood transfusions, and Stage 3 tearing with no epidural in the birth of our first 8-pound, 14-ounce baby. In the hospital delivering our second—8 pounds, 12 ounces—I was in so much pain that I told him I would scream for help if he didn’t get a doctor. He disappeared and soon the anesthesiologist appeared. Telling the story later, he boasted to friends that he hadn’t actually talked to anyone; he’d only pantomimed heeding my wishes so I’d stop complaining. 

He attended a four-day bachelor party when our youngest was seven weeks old, leaving me alone with a preschooler and a newborn. Six months later, when the marrying couple wanted to gift me a massage to thank me for officiating their wedding, he declined on my behalf: it would create too much childcare work for him. 

***

“It’s a nation of fuckin’ rats.”

A question I am still confronting: who is the rat? And what does the rat do?

The rat is a specter over all these films. There is a rat in the Special Investigations Unit of the Massachusetts State Police,  a rat in Costello’s outfit, a dead rat in the basement of the Boston Globe. 

The Departed is a successive termination of rats: Sheen dies, Nicholson dies, Leo dies, Matt the rat looks like he’s going to survive, only to be shot as the film lands. The film conveys moral ambivalence, a basement-level resistance to condemning rattitude, by way of making almost all of its characters, ultimately, rats. Does this accrue to suggest that rattitude is inevitable, canny, corrupt, or all three? The film concludes with the rat on the monument. 

“Francis. It’s a nation of fuckin’ rats,” says French on the obelisk bridge, the Dropkick Murphys screaming.

However, Good Will Hunting depicts institutions as forces for good: places where a kindly therapist, rich woman, or self-interested professor might reupholster your dingy inner life. But the film also illustrates intimacy’s essential intrusiveness, and rigorous disclosure’s capacity for transformation. (“It’s not your fault. No, listen to me, it’s not your fault.”) It is not quite a film about ratting, but it is entirely a film about the necessity of telling on yourself. 

Where ratting—for our discursive purposes, exposing what power holders are plotting—would violate the snitches-get-stiches code of conduct in the character logic of The Departed, The Town, or even Argo, the action of ratting is ethically central to Spotlight’s mission. Ratting out the archdiocese, most of all, but also ratting out its enablers: the lawyers, judges, bureaucrats, fundraisers. Concentric circles of rattitude. Spotlight is, tip to tail, an argument for ratting as a morally crucial, incontrovertibly necessary tool of social progress.

To achieve this, Spotlight moves the goalposts on who the protagonists are and thus who the rat is. Its rats would be abhorrent to the Affleck milieu. Truthful storytelling itself is a form of ratting, of risk, exposure, and vulnerability, as evidenced by Will Hunting’s elaborate lies about his origins. Secular investigative journalism acts directly against Boston’s code of silence, as evidenced by the church’s repeated attempts to exert pressure on the editors. If it is the charge not to rat which fortifies the fragile, common-enemy-intimate, masculine bonds of the Affleck monuments against outside scrutiny, it is indeed the charge to rat that distinguishes the Spotlight reporters as morally exceptional to their ethically dingy surroundings. 

“Rat on the monument” could be Spotlight’s logline. 

***

“You have to take it.”

No one wants to become the first woman in her entire lineage to ever leave a husband, but I did. For decades, I believed that he showed little regard for my feelings because he was fired in a crucible where feelings could never enter, in a Commonwealth where male emotion had been systematically murdered for generations. But I realized that even if that were true, cruelty is like bile: no matter its source, it chews a hole through everything tender. So I fled for a new life for which I had no model. 

I had to choose rattitude. I have learned that building a rathole is the only way anyone escapes the vast, dingy Boston of the mind. 

No one gives you freedom. You have to take it. Sometimes to perform your best function, you have to stand alone.

  1. For this personality-driven investigation of masculinity narratives, I opt to reference actor names rather than character names.