
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. So says Carl Sagan, anyway, echoing a 19th-century maxim popularized by contemporary UFO skywatchers who Want To Believe. The concept applies to earthbound concerns as well and has inspired frothy debate among scientists, legal scholars, philosophers, and nitpickers alike. The interplay between evidence and absence is a powerful, often invisible force in Satyajit Ray’s deceptively simple Days and Nights In the Forest (1970). The film’s ostensible small-scale neorealist drama contains a whole internal cosmology of four middle-aged men in crisis, where the black holes of negative space exert the same gravitational power as the stars themselves.
The first notable absence—the almost total lack of backstory—makes itself known gradually at first, and then dazzlingly, much the way a long, dollying one-shot take gathers virtuosity. In Ray’s tale of four old friends on vacation, the origins of their friendship go almost entirely unmentioned. A single brief snippet of dialogue reveals that they once worked on a literary journal together. Otherwise, their shared history is entirely conveyed through gestures and jokes and the overlapping configurations of their interactions with one another. It’s a small miracle the way the viewer not only fully understands each of the four main characters over the course of the opening scene—a car trip en route to a secluded rental property—but that we fully understand the way they understand one another.
In his tremendous essays collection Our Films, Their Films, the multi-disciplinary master Ray—who not only wrote, directed, and often scored his own films, but was also a prolific novelist and critic—writes that, “as a student of painting, I had been drawn towards far-eastern calligraphy, which goes to the heart of perceived reality and expresses it by means of minimal brush strokes applied with maximum discipline.” That’s an accurate description of Ray’s own bold, elegant style. He later praises the “calligraphic grace” of the great silent filmmakers, which is present here, even in this quite talky film.
In the deft, subtly revealing opening sequence, the uptight Sanjoy (Subhendu Chatterjee) reads from a dubious guidebook describing the women of the rural vista they’re driving toward, while the clownish Shekhar (Rabi Ghosh) endlessly pesters him. Their handsome pal Hari (Samit Bhanja) snoozes in the back seat, entirely aloof. Ashim (Soumitra Chatterjee), the driver, is the obvious leader of the quartet. The four friends’ banter en route to their isolated vacation bungalow is spiked with unexplained references and inside jokes, and reveals all the necessary details: Hari is a rugby star still wallowing in the wake of a bad romance. Sanjoy is an idealist grinding under the weight of the compromises he makes to care for his entire family. Shekhar is an amiable degenerate gambler.
The four men remain close despite the perpendicular trajectories of their lives. Though they are on distinctly different journeys, they all seek the same thing in the forest: absence. Absence of responsibility, absence of modernity, absence of the rigid expectations of the class system, and an absence of the rules and restrictions in metropolitan Calcutta that have awkwardly shaped them into what they are—four people recognizable to one another, yet increasingly unfamiliar to themselves.
As is so often the case in Ray’s work, the great filmmaker identifies singularly Indian tropes and traditions that hum with universal resonance. The Cinema Of Satyajit Ray author Darius Cooper quotes the historian Richard Lannoy’s explanation of the long Indian tradition of the forest as a retreat from “increasingly differentiated” society where “social discipline called for by the new productive techniques created a sense of anxiety.” No doubt true, but this isn’t exactly a nationally isolated phenomenon. Henry David Thoreau and the Unabomber would like a word. The difference between the pressures of capitalism and Puritanism versus traditionalism and caste are particular but not exclusive. (Perhaps that’s why Ray’s films translate so well, literally and figuratively; Noah Baumbach’s recent Jay Kelly is basically a straight-up uncredited remake of Ray’s superior 1966 film, The Hero.)
In Days and Nights In the Forest, the bourgeois Bengalis exoticize the darker-skinned local women, assume reflexive superiority over the men, and regard the more egalitarian, less modernized way of life with a blend of envy and condescension. This is not an unfamiliar dynamic to an American, either.
Maybe here in the woods they can relocate themselves, can be unburdened of the strictures and structures that more than just confine them. Even worse, they have begun to contort themselves around these rules and cultural norms the way a tree warps itself to grow around a metal fence post.
***
It’s never too early to begin your mid-life crisis.
The average lifespan of an American male is 75.6, 81.4 for a woman. But, let’s face it, just barely half the population makes it to the median, by definition. Knock a few years off for bad genes and bad behavior, divide by two, and you’re overdue for your scheduled existential reckoning before you’re 35. Time’s a-wasting to look back on all that wasted time.
Of course, mid-life crises are about more than just mortality, they’re also about malleability. The lurking fear isn’t just that you’ll die soon, but that you’ll live like this until you do. Middle age is the pivot point at which you’re equally haunted by the past and the future. The clay is baked, and now you’ve hardened into the shape of all the choices you’ve made thus far. Another word for hardened is ossified.
Hari laments that he gave up his collegiate ambitions to pursue cricket. Now no one takes him seriously, including the sophisticated girlfriend who rejected him for his intellectual frivolity. Sanjoy has compromised his political values in pursuit of a secure life he can’t fully enjoy because he’s too timid to admit his crush on his boss’s daughter. Though he’s successful in business, Ashim recognizes his own phoniness as he flashes back to cocktail parties with his colleagues, fearing perhaps that he will fully become the person he is pretending to be. The only one who can escape this dread of a narrowing future is Shekhar, but only because he has no such ambitions. He’s as much a cautionary tale as he is a model for spiritual balance.
And so the men, in extremis, behave badly. It’s a hallowed tradition of the male mid-life crisis movie, ranging from the sacred (Husbands) to the profane (Very Bad Things) to the Wal-Mart discount version (Wild Hogs). They get sloppy drunk, maudlin, and even cruel. Hari brazenly woos a local woman (Simi Garewal) and publicly humiliates the local men. The behavior is spurred on by the movie’s most notable absence: the feminine perspective.
That changes when Shekhar spots a pair of well-dressed metropolitan women in the house down the road. The women turn out to be sisters-in-law; the guarded, sharp-eyed Aparna (the beguiling, legendary Sharmila Tagore) and her welcoming, widowed sister-in-law Jaya (Kaberi Bose), who are staying at the family vacation getaway with Aparna’s father and Jaya’s young son. Because of their class consciousness, the men, mostly unconcerned with the provincial local women, are thrown into a tizzy by the presence of these women from their own walk of life. They abandon their mutual pledge not to shave, become shy about bathing in the well by the house, and inquire about current events even though they have burned the newspaper as a symbol of their disconnect from the city.
In the pivotal scene of the film, the whole group plays a parlor game of memory, predicated on recalling the sequential order of a list of famous people. The names each character chooses, and the way each one plays the game, is as obliquely revealing as the interplay in the film’s initial road-trip sequence. The contest comes down to Aparna and Ashim, the latter of whom remains flummoxed by his beautiful but withholding counterpart. It’s here he begins to realize that his befuddlement over her omnivorous cultural tastes and her appraisal of the four men might owe more to his own lack of understanding than her eccentricity.
In the film’s climax, which quite literally affirms its status as a carnivalesque by taking place at an actual carnival, the four men diverge into their own stories. Ashim and Aparna’s burgeoning romance takes center stage, contrasted by the disastrous interaction between Sanjoy and Jaya, in which Sanjoy proves incapable of escaping the confines of his own self-conception. Aparna gently forces Ashim to confront the limits of his certitude. She wasn’t just playing the memory game, she was playing him. She is, in fact, a literal genius of sorts who keeps her insights to herself, whereas Ashim projects his onto everyone else.
In giving himself over to Aparna’s perspective, Ashim has an epiphany about the limits of his own understanding. Rather than be devastated by it, like Sanjoy, he is enlivened by the possibilities—not just of love, but an escape from his self-imposed torpor. Ray is too nuanced a storyteller to make an explicitly proscriptive film, but among the four friends who represent different perspectives on middle age, Ashim is clearly the model for growth. His story here echoes the conclusion of another great collaboration between Ray and Soumitra Chatterjee, The World Of Apu (1959). Transcendence is elusive, but to even have any hope of obtaining it, one must stop insisting on the evidence of one’s own opinion and embrace the possibilities presented by absence.
